The Noise That Got Promoted
Look around your office. You’ve got the harmless ones who live for coffee breaks, the quiet ones holding the place together — and then there’s that one. The walking microphone. He interrupts mid-sentence, rephrases your idea louder, adds a sprinkle of self-importance, and suddenly he’s the “visionary.” The room claps like he’s reinvented oxygen. By Monday, he’s promoted. You know exactly who I mean — the noise that somehow got mistaken for leadership. You sit there wondering how charm without content keeps floating upward while competence politely waits for recognition that never comes. The truth? Workplaces don’t reward wisdom; they reward theatre. Confidence looks like competence, arrogance looks like authority, and narcissism… well, it photographs beautifully on LinkedIn. We say we want humble leaders, but the promotion system keeps falling for the same act — the louder the performance, the faster the standing ovation.
How Narcissists Perfect the Illusion of Leadership
Narcissists don’t lead — they perform. Every meeting is a stage, every nod an audience cue. They’ve mastered the art of mistaking visibility for value. Their confidence reads like competence, their dominance feels like direction, and their ability to sound certain fools everyone desperate for stability. They wear enthusiasm like armour — loud enough to drown out anyone who might expose the hollowness underneath. The secret is simple: they don’t crave approval, they collect it. And the mask? It isn’t fake. It’s professional-grade — polished through years of feedback, flattery, and zero introspection. The tragedy isn’t that they fool people; it’s that most of us want to be fooled. Certainty feels safer than honesty — and narcissists know exactly how to sell it.
How Modern Workplaces Reward Ego Over Substance
The real problem isn’t the narcissist — it’s the structure that keeps promoting them. Modern workplaces mistake visibility for value. Those who speak the most are seen the most, and those who are seen the most are rewarded for simply existing in the spotlight. Performance is no longer measured in outcomes, but in optics. HR calls it “leadership presence.” It’s really just volume management — the ability to sound decisive while saying nothing. Narcissists don’t exploit the system; they fit it perfectly. They reflect its priorities back at itself — image over substance, ambition over integrity. Even LinkedIn has turned self-promotion into currency. The result is predictable: a corporate ecosystem that manufactures leaders who can command a room but can’t guide one. We’ve automated admiration, and the machine keeps promoting mirrors.
The Cost of Promoting Confidence Over Competence
The damage never happens in headlines — it happens in silence. Teams crumble one meeting at a time. Ideas die before they’re spoken, strangled by micromanagement and blame. The best people leave quietly, the rest stay out of fear. Soon, fear starts wearing a badge called “discipline,” and exhaustion is rebranded as “commitment.” Productivity becomes theatre, creativity turns to compliance. Under narcissistic leadership, organisations stop growing — they just keep moving, loudly, in circles. And the cruel irony? The system calls it success right up until the moment it collapses. The empire of ego always collapses — it just gets a corner office first.
The Reflection We Deserve
We keep promoting narcissists because they mirror the illusion we secretly admire — that volume equals vision and certainty equals strength. They play the role we’ve all been trained to applaud: confident, unshakable, always right, even when they’re not. The real tragedy isn’t that they fool the system; it’s that the system keeps asking for more of them. We built workplaces that reward performance over principle, and then act surprised when the performers take over the stage. Maybe they’re not the problem at all. Maybe they’re just the reflection we deserve.
Of course, not everyone who rises is a narcissist. Some are just really, really good at reading people — and using that. Manipulation Isn’t Genius — It’s Human explains why it works so easily on the rest of us.
Ever worked for one of these “visionaries”?
The kind who called chaos “strategy” and wore confidence like a bulletproof vest?
Tell me about it — I collect survival stories from the frontlines of corporate theatre.
Share your experience in the comments or email me your story.
The best ones might shape my next article: